|
Demonstrations
of High-Speed Phenomena
Scripts for effective demonstrations of some interesting
phenomena are given below.
The Demonstrations
- Stroboscope and fan
- Lifetime of a bursting balloon
- Waveforms on a plucked cord
- Shape of a racquetball in collision
Demonstration 1. Stroboscope and fan
Cautions: Since this demonstration uses flashing
lights, the audience needs to be warned that flashing lights have
been known to cause seizures. Even for people who are not
susceptible to seizures, strobe lights can create nausea or
headaches, especially when used in a room without ambient
light Having a low light level in the room is helpful but may
make the demonstration less effective. In that case, don't leave the
strobe on for long periods of time.
Equipment:
Electronic stroboscope
Electronic flash unit
Large fan with variable-speed control (blades should be replaced
with a large, black cardboard disc)
Post cards or pictures taped to cardboard disc
Post-It note taped to the perimeter of the disc and extending
several inches beyond
Equipment note:
The electronic flash unit must be adjusted to give a very short
burst of light. This can be achieved by using a flash unit with
automatic exposure control. If, for example, you're using a
Vivitar 283, set the dial on the light sensor (labeled auto-thyristor)
to yellow. Control of flash duration is described in greater detail here.
Method:
- Turn the fan on to a medium speed. When the room lights are
on, only a blur is seen.
- Leave the room lights on and discharge the electronic flash
unit toward the fan. The blades can be seen for an instant
amidst the blur. Show this several times.
- With the room lights still on, turn on the stroboscope,
describe what it does and how frequency is controlled. Turn off
the room lights and adjust the stroboscope frequency to make the
fan blades appear stopped. Ask for an explanation of why the
blades appear stopped.
- Hold a stick just outside the tips of the fan blades until the
Post-It note strikes it repeatedly. The sound of the note
hitting the stick repeatedly will be heard even though no
apparent contact is seen.
- Turn off the fan.
Rationale: This demonstration shows that the blurring that is
common when viewing fast-moving objects (rotating, in this case) is
due, at least partially, to the lighting under which the objects are
viewed. (This may also have something to do with a limitation of the
brain to process sequential images when displayed without breaks.)
When the same object is viewed under a single, brief flash of light
(about 30 millionths of a second in this case), all of its detail
can be seen. If the flash is repeated at a rate that is equal to the
rotational frequency of the object, the object is seen as if
stopped. This is only an illusion, as is evidenced by the Post-It
note striking the stick repeatedly.
Conjecture: The blurring seen under continuous lighting
might also have something to do with a limitation of the brain to
process sequential images when those images are displayed without
breaks. We know from motion pictures that the brain can process and
interpret images of moving objects when the images are flashed
rapidly by our eyes as a sequence of individual frames.
Back to top
Demonstration 2. Lifetime of a bursting of
a balloon
Equipment:
Electronic flash unit
Sound trigger and cord to flash unit
Balloons and needle
Equipment notes:
- The electronic flash unit must be adjusted to give a very
short burst of light. This can be achieved by using a flash unit
with automatic exposure control. If, for example, you're using a
Vivitar 283, set the dial on the light sensor (labeled auto-thyristor)
to yellow. Control of flash duration is described in greater
detail here.
- A piezoelectric sound trigger works fine. Here are links on
this site to information about sound triggers:
basic information
how to make a sound
trigger
trigger from Radio Shack
components
Method:
- After seeing Demonstration 1, students
should understand why they don’t normally see the rip in a
bursting balloon. In order to see the rip, the balloon needs to
be illuminated with a flash of light that is significantly
shorter than the amount of time it takes a balloon to completely
burst apart. Invite a volunteer to hold the flash unit on a
balloon. Will he/she be able to discharge the flash unit as the
balloon is bursting? It will be apparent to nearly everyone that
this can only be done by chance--not by design.
- Show and describe a sound trigger and how it works. Have
another volunteer hold the sound trigger very close to the
balloon as it is being popped. A third volunteer can hold the
balloon. Pop several balloons under the same conditions to make
sure everyone sees the rip. Invite people to describe what they
see.
- Move the sound trigger about a meter away and pop the balloon
again. Ask for someone to explain why much less of the balloon
is visible. Knowing the speed of sound (about 340 m/s), a lower
limit for the lifetime of the bursting balloon can be obtained.
The time for sound to travel a meter is about 1/340 s. (This
would be about 3 milliseconds.) The duration of the burst will
be greater than this since it takes a short time for the sound
trigger and flash circuitry to respond. (This is probably a few
milliseconds.)
Rationale: This demonstration provides a unique and dramatic
experience in measuring a very short time interval. There are few if
any opportunities in a secondary-school science classroom to make
such measurements without the use of electronic timing equipment.
The demonstration also provides opportunities--depending on the
class and the teacher--to use the definition of speed, do
estimation, and deal with metric units of distance.
Back to top
Demonstration 3. Waveforms on a plucked cord
Equipment:
Electronic flash unit
Interrupter photogate and cord to flash unit
Elastic cord
Equipment notes:
- The electronic flash unit must be adjusted to give a very
short burst of light. This can be achieved by using
a flash unit with automatic exposure control. If,
for example, you're using a Vivitar 283, set the dial on the
light sensor (labeled auto-thyristor) to yellow. Control
of flash duration is described in greater detail here.
- The photogate trigger circuit is the one described in the
links below. The use of an interrupter is highly
recommended. These are available as part of the kit listed
below.
basic information
how to make a
photogate trigger
- The elastic cord can be a length of small diameter shock cord
or elastic strips such as those found in fabric stores.
Rubber bands also work, but they're really too short for an
effective demonstration.
Method:
- Have two volunteers come up to take the ends of the cord and
stretch it. Pluck the cord at the center and ask people to
describe the blurred waveform that they see. Now ask them to
predict what shape the cord would take almost immediately after
release, that is, before the cord has time to return to its
original, resting position.
- Ask for another volunteer to hold the flash unit, aiming it at
the cord. Show how the flash unit is set off when something is
passed through the photogate. Note that the photogate is
composed of two components, an emitter of light and a detector
of light. In this case, the light is infrared and invisible to
our eyes, similar to that of a TV remote. When light is blocked
from reaching the detector, the flash unit is signaled to
discharge. Motion detectors operate on similar principles. Some
examples are closing elevator doors that sense when someone is
going through and the security detector in the corner of the
classroom that senses when something is moving in the room.
- Stretch the cord upward at the center, ready to be released.
Position the interrupter about a third of the way from the pluck
point to either end. With the room lights off, release the cord.
Have someone describe what they saw. Try again with the
interrupter nearer the pluck point. Then try with the
interrupter closer and closer to one end of the cord. Note how
the trapezoidal shape is retained in all cases.
- Repeat step 3 for a pluck point that is much nearer one end
than the other. Note that this is the shape to be expected for
waves on a plucked string instrument such as a guitar. (The
amplitude will, of course, not be nearly as great.)
- Note that the trapezoidal or triangular wave shapes are not
retained for long as the oscillation of the cord progresses. The
curved shape seen under normal room lighting is characteristic
of the shape of the cord after it has oscillated many cycles.
Rationale: One purpose of the demonstration is to show a
common phenomenon that most people have never seen or suspected.
Many people are surprised and fascinated by what they see. The
demonstration has value as a lead-in or supplement to a discussion
of standing waves in an introductory physics class. As such, it
would have more pedagogical value in the spring term when most
physics classes are studying waves.
Back to top
Demonstration 4. Shape of a racquetball in
collision
Equipment:
Electronic flash unit
Sound trigger and cord to flash unit
Racquetball
Flashlight
Equipment notes:
- The electronic flash unit must be adjusted to give a very
short burst of light. This can be achieved by using
a flash unit with automatic exposure control. If,
for example, you're using a Vivitar 283, set the dial on the
light sensor (labeled auto-thyristor) to yellow. Control
of flash duration is described in greater detail here.
- A piezoelectric sound trigger may not work well for this
demonstration. A trigger with a wider frequency response
is recommended. The trigger described in FAQ
works well.
Method:
- This is best done in a room with a high ceiling where the ball
can be thrown forcefully against the floor without danger of
breaking ceiling tiles or lights on the rebound. Place the flash
on the floor pointed at the spot where the ball will hit. People
should sit on the floor behind or to the side of the flash so
that they are not blinded by it. Place the sound trigger on a
carpet scrap about 3 feet from the collision site. Have a
volunteer aim the flashlight a distance away so that there's
enough light to see by but not enough to overpower the flash.
- Throw the racquetball down to the floor or have a volunteer
throw it. Ask people to describe what they see from their
viewpoint near the floor. Repeat a few times. Then move the
sound trigger further and further away to see changes in the
shape of the ball during collision. At some point, perhaps
a meter or less away, the racquetball will be seen with an
interesting dimpled shape. This shape occurs because parts of
the ball near the outer perimeter are in the process of
rebounding while the top of the ball is still going down.
Rationale: Like the plucked cord, this demonstration allows
people to observe a phenomenon that will be a real discovery for
most of them. The explanation is fairly simple in qualitative
terms. For introductory physics students who are used to
simplifying the study of colliding objects by treating them as
points, the racquetball collisions let them see a real colliding
object.
Back to top
|